Extract from review by Bertha Chiroro (EISA) in the Journal of African Elections Vol. 4 No. 1 (pp 181-183):
"... a valuable resource for readers seeking to understand South Africa's past, present and future policies on transformation. It is particularly useful for students of South African politics, civil society, and anyone who wishes to celebrate the achievements of the first ten years of South Africa's democracy, the way it has dealt with apartheid's past and the challenges of growth that lie ahead."
Extract from review by Timothy M. Shaw (Royal Roads University, Canada) in Round Table 386 September 2006 pp. 646-647:
"Social science in South Africa has always been more extensive than elsewhere on the continent especially over the past decade of democratic governance; with this impressive collection, it can now claim to be superior. And as an increasingly recognized emerging economy, South Africa's analysis and practice have a relevance to others in this ebullient middle stratum such as Brazil and India. Symptomatically, China in both Africa and South Africa is the focus of a pair of timely chapters.But the volume also holds relevance to other comparative fields and debates in addition to those about the 'developmental state',such as democracy, ecology, education, energy, gender, labour, political economy, race etc,as well as more parochial questions of African development such as the Commission for Africa and NEPAD."
Extract from review by Michael H. Allen (Bryn Mawr College) in Africa Today Winter 2006 Vol 53 Issue 2 p.111-113:
"The distinct advantage of State of the Nation is that it also locates the specific themes relevant to South Africa within global dynamics that are changing economic structures, class politics, and the character of governance and the state everywhere. This arrangement makes the volume potentially valuable to scholars and activists in the geopolitics of energy and global financial markets, the symbolic politics of sport, the transnational sociology of Chinese diaspora, and other fields. It presents rich and recent data on empirical trends in the aspects of the reality that are vital for watchers of South Africa. In some chapters, the contributors connect their data to scholarly debates and bibliographies pertaining to other parts of the world."
Click on the links below to read the reviews:
Star 08 May 2006
Succeed 01 Mar 2006 [1]
Succeed 01 Mar 2006 [2]
Enterprise 02 March 2006 [1]
Enterprise 02 March 2006 [2]
Burger (Kaap) 20 February 2006
Burger (Oos-Kaap) 20 February 2006
Saturday Dispatch 21 January 2006
Sowetan 17 January 2006
Mail and Guardian Business 6 January 2006
Cape Times 2 December 2005
Cape Times 30 November 2005
Sowetan 29 November 2005
Cape Times 28 November 2005
Sunday Independant 27 November 2005
Business Day 17 November 2005
Cape Times 15 November 2005
Cape Times 11 November 2005
Daily News 10 November 2005
Pretoria News 10 November 2005
Business Day 8 November 2005
Sunday Independent 6 November 2005
Volksblad 2 November 2005 (1)
Volksblad 2 November 2005 (2)
Volksblad 2 November 2005 (3)
Beeld 2 November 2005 (1)
Beeld 2 November 2005 (2)
Business Report National 2 November 2005
Cape Argus City Late 1 November 2005
Cape Times 1 November 2005
Pretoria News 1 November 2005
Star 1 November 2005
Sunday Independent 30 October 2005
Business Day 28 October 2005
Business Day 25 October 2005
Business Day 21 October 2005
Reviews of previous volumes...
'At the same time as covering what is essential, the editors have also managed to include some issues that may be seen as peripheral to central concerns, but providing wider coverage of important indicators of the state of the nation, and noting issues that need attention. Altogether an important voice...'
Gerry Mare, Transformation
'The HSRC has made a massive contribution to the analysis of the new South Africa with these volumes…no academic, student or policymaker can afford to ignore this huge opus on the South African condition.'
Ben Turok MP, New Agenda
'For those who remember the South African Review series from the 1980s and bemoaned its passing, State of the Nation is a worthy successor.'
Barbara Manning, Daily Dispatch
'As long as the HSRC publishes an independent annual review of this quality, there is good reason for optimism about the survival of free speech and a vigorous climate of debate…the HSRC is performing an indispensable service to the nation.'
Gerald Shaw, Cape Times