The Human Sciences Research Council (HSRC)

Visit South Africa's official Covid-19 resource portal
2287  Large

Critics of privatisation are often told they present no alternatives. This book takes up that challenge, proposing conceptual models for what constitutes an alternative to privatisation and analyses what makes them successful (or not), backed up by empirical data on creative public service initiatives in over 40 countries in the Global South. This groundbreaking study provides a robust platform for comparisons across regions and sectors, with a focus on health, water and electricity. Alternatives to Privatisation is a compelling study and has been written by leading academics, practitioners and activists in the field.

Here is a book that many have been waiting for: an empirical, theoretical and normative case for defending and innovating the public. In resisting neoliberalism we need to show that there are viable alternatives to the privatisation and commercialisation of essential services. This book does not romanticise the state, or community, and illustrates that the public comes in many forms and guises; both good and bad. The public is a terrain on which people must struggle if we are to realise our commitments to social, cultural and economic rights.

David McCoy - University College London and Peoples Health Movement

At a time that neoliberal solutions to social services have lost credibility, this book argues convincingly that alternatives to privatisation exist and are often more effective than private enterprises. Drawing on examples in Africa, Asia, and Latin America, this book drives home the lesson that broad-based consultation and participation in service delivery is an essential ingredient of success.

Walden Bello - Author, academic, and political analyst

Product information

Format : 240mm x 168mm
Pages : 532
ISBN 10 : 978-07969-2377-6
ISBN 13 : 978-07969-2377-6
Publish Year : 2012
Rights : Africa Rights Only

List of tables
List of figures
Acknowledgements

1 Introduction: In search of alternatives to privatisation
DAVID A MCDONALD AND GREG RUITERS

2 Weighing the options: Methodological considerations
DAVID A MCDONALD AND GREG RUITERS

PART I Actors, issues and ideologies
3 Terrains of neoliberalism: Constraints and opportunities for alternative models of service delivery
BEN FINE AND DAVID HALL

4 Transformative resistance: The role of labour and trade unions in alternatives to privatisation
HILARY WAINWRIGHT

5 Gendering justice, building alternative futures
CHANDRA TALPADE MOHANTY AND SARAH MIRAGLIA

6 Social movement struggles for public services
SUSAN SPRONK AND PHILIPP TERHORST

7 Careful what you ask for: State-led alternatives to privatisation
DAVID A MCDONALD AND GREG RUITERS

PART II Sectoral and regional reviews
Asia: Regional overview
JENINA JOY CHAVEZ

8 Creating, reclaiming, defending: Non-commercialised alternatives in the health sector in Asia
AMIT SENGUPTA

9 Springs of hope: Alternatives to commercialisation of water resources and services in Asia
BUENAVENTURA DARGANTES, CHERYL BATISTEL AND MARY ANN MANAHAN

10 The public in Asia power
NEPOMUCENO MALALUAN
Africa: Regional overview
GREG RUITERS

11 African triage: Assessing alternatives to health care privatisation south of the Sahara
YOSWA M. DAMBISYA AND HYACINTH EME ICHOKU

12 Where have all the alternatives gone? The shrinking of African water policy options
KATE BAYLISS AND AL-HASSAN ADAM

13 Electrifying Africa: Turning a continental challenge into a peoples opportunity
TERRI HATHAWAY
Latin America and the Caribbean: Regional overview
SUSAN SPRONK

14 Progressive alternatives in primary health care in Latin America
LUIS ORTIZ HERNNDEZ, ILIANA CAMACHO CUAPIO, CATALINA EIBENSCHUTZ HARTMAN AND SILVIA TAMEZ GONZLEZ

15 Struggles for water justice in Latin America: Public and social-public alternatives
SUSAN SPRONK, CARLOS CRESPO AND MARCELA OLIVERA

16 Alternatives in the electricity sector in Latin America 453
DANIEL CHAVEZ

PART III Looking ahead
17 Conclusion: Ways forward for alternatives in health care, water and electricity
DAVID A MCDONALD AND GREG RUITERS

Contributors

Index

David A McDonald is Professor of Global Development Studies at Queens University, Canada, and Co-Director of the Municipal Services Project.

Greg Ruiters is Professor of Governance and Public Policy at the University of the Western Cape, South Africa, and Co-Director of the Municipal Services Project.

Share this

You might also consider these related books

2296  Large

COSATUS Contested Legacy
South African trade unions in the second decade of democracy

Images of striking COSATU workers, singing, marching and toyi-toying are a familiar sight for most South Africans and external observers of the country's politics. Similarly, COSATU's feisty general secretary, Zwelinzima Vavi has become a household name, commanding respect and admiration among millions and loathing and fear among his enemies and those who are on the receiving end of his fiery political oratory. But how much do we know about what COSATU workers think about their workplaces, their unions, politics and the economy? What influences COSATU members' decisions to vote for a particular political party? Why has COSATU women members' support for the ANC declined? Why do some union members think there may be good reasons to assault non-strikers and scabs during strikes? What do unionised workers think of service delivery and what role did they play in the recent spate of service delivery protests? These and many other questions are examined in this volume which is based on the fourth run of the COSATU Workers' Survey conducted a few months before the 2009 elections. Contrary to stereotypes reproduced in the media and other public platforms which portray trade union members as a herd led by all-powerful 'union bosses', A Contested Legacy deftly presents a picture of a multifaceted organisation whose members are steeped in the traditions of internal democracy, leadership accountability and mandated decision-making. But these traditions are not static. They are fiercely contested among different groups and categories of union members women and men; migrant and urban workers; skilled and unskilled workers; blue collar and white collar and professional workers; permanent and part-time and casual workers.

Product information

Format : 210mm x 148mm (Soft Cover)
Pages : 328
ISBN 10 : 978-07969-2395-0
ISBN 13 : 978-07969-2395-0
Publish Year : 2012
Rights : Africa Rights Only
Price R 295.00
City Of Broken Dreams

City of Broken Dreams
Myth-making, nationalism and the university in an African rust belt city

City of Broken Dreams brings the global debate about the urban university to bear on the realities of South African rust-belt cities through a detailed case study of the Eastern Cape motor city of East London, a site of significant industrial job losses over the past two decades.

Product information

Format : 235mm x 168mm (Soft Cover)
Pages : 320
ISBN 13 : 978-0-7969-2454-4
Publish Year : January 2019
Rights : Worldwide rights, excluding USA and US territories
Price R 350.00
2225  Large

Attitudes to work and social security in South Africa

This paper presents findings from a module in the HSRC's 2006 South African Social Attitudes Survey that was designed by the Centre for the Analysis of South African Social Policy at the University of Oxford. Respondents were asked for their views on issues relating to the importance of work and the relationship between social grants and employment. The findings demonstrate a strong attachment to the labour market among the unemployed, support for more financial assistance for poor people including those who are unable to find work, and no evidence that social grants in South Africa foster a 'dependency culture'.

Product information

Format : 280mm x 210mm (Soft Cover)
Pages : 28
ISBN 10 : 0-7969-2219-5
ISBN 13 : 978-07969-2219-9
Publish Year : 2008
Rights : World Rights
Price R 98.00
2137  Large

Multinationals on the Periphery
DaimlerChrysler South Africa, human capital upgrading and regional economic development

Utilising the DaimlerChrysler human resources upgrade in one of South Africas least developed provinces as the basis, this is a well-developed case study of the relationship between human capital in host economies and international capital inflows. It describes how DaimlerChrysler upgraded human resources in its East London plant where the company manufactures the Mercedes C-Class model for export. Lorentzen explores the extent and depth of the upgrading along and beyond the automotive supply chain, and its repercussions on local education and training institutions. Finally, he analyses how foreign direct investment and local industrial development interact in the short and medium term, and hypothesises as to the possible longer-term outcomes in the absence of proper regional economic planning.

Product information

Format : 148mm x 210mm
Pages : 44
ISBN 10 : 0-7969-2131-8
ISBN 13 : 978-07969-2131-4
Publish Year : 2006
Price R 95.00