The Human Sciences Research Council (HSRC)

Studying While Black

Between 2013 and 2017, a team of researchers from the Human Sciences Research Council undertook a longitudinal qualitative study that tracked eighty students from eight diverse universities in South Africa and documented their experiences at these higher education institutions. Midway through the study, the student protests erupted and focused national attention on many of the stories we had already heard. In the subsequent years of the study, we also heard from students who were actively involved in these transformation struggles as well as those who sat on the side-lines.

Studying While Black is an intimate portrait of the many ways in which students in South Africa experience university, and the centrality of race and geography in their quest for education and ultimately emancipation. Students voices can be heard directly in a 45 minute documentary that accompanied this study entitled Ready or Not!: Black students’ experiences of South African universities – freely available on social media.

Product information

Format : 240mm x 168mm (Soft Cover)
Pages : 272
ISBN 13 : 978-0-7969-2508-4
Publish Year : March 2018
Rights : World Rights

Chapter 1 South African students and their struggles: An in-depth view
Literature review
Conceptual framework
Research questions and study design
Navigating the annexes of this book

Chapter 2 Participants and their institutions: Individuals in context
Findings
Family
Community
Schools
Perceptions of success
Visions for life
Institutions of higher learning
Discussion

Chapter 3 Navigating race in higher education and beyond
Findings
Inclusion and identity politics
Understanding legacies of apartheid
Decolonisation and rethinking the university
Discussion
Recommendations

Chapter 4 Gender dynamics and (in)equality of experiences
Findings
Understanding the meaning of patriarchy and gender difference on campus
Progress and challenges in addressing gender equity on campuses
Gender identity, gender expression and sexual orientation at university
Discussion
Recommendations

Chapter 5 Language and power as structural barriers
Findings
Language privilege
Background disadvantage
‘Good English and accents’
Discussion
Recommendations

Chapter 6 Obstacles to access and participation in universities
Findings
Academic obstacles
Financial obstacles
Financially interlinked obstacles: Accommodation and travel
Additional challenges
Discussion
Recommendations

Chapter 7 Students’ perspectives and strategies for success
Findings
Individual factors: Focus, self-reliance and academic interest
Micro factors: Supportive networks
Educational resources
Macro factors: Religiosity
Discussion
Recommendations

Chapter 8 Interventionist research strategies for emancipation
Strategies for emancipation
Discussion
Recommendations

Chapter 9 Conclusion: Skills and systemic change needed
How inequality is manifested
Overall findings of the study
Recommendations
Conclusion

Appendix 1 Ethics: Sample information sheet and consent form
Appendix 2 University sketches
Appendix 3 Recruitment poster
Appendix 4 Annual participant interview schedules
Appendix 5 Participant profiles and biographies
Appendix 6 Social network interview questions
Appendix 7 Recommendations by stakeholder category


Emma Arogundade is a former senior researcher at the Human Sciences Research Council and a PhD candidate in the Department of Sociology at the University of Cape Town. Her thesis explores issues of morality, racialised identity and restitution in South Africa. She holds an MPhil in Critical Diversity Studies from the University of Cape Town and has lectured extensively on diversity, race, class and gender and on community development, both at UCT and at the School for International Training. She is the co-author of Moral Eyes: Cultivating Youth Engagement on Privilege, Injustice and Restitution (2018), has edited three volumes in the ‘Celebrating Africa’ series at the University of Cape Town, and has published two journal articles and two book chapters. Her work centres on identities, feminisms and narrative theory, using these frameworks to explore issues from community development, to motherhood, and moral identities to intersecting axes of privilege, oppression and forms of resistance.

Adam Cooper is a research specialist at the Human Sciences Research Council and research associate in the Department of Education Policy Studies at Stellenbosch University. Before joining the HSRC he was a National Research Foundation of South Africa postdoctoral scholar abroad, based at the Graduate Center at the City University of New York. He was the recipient of a Commonwealth Split-site PhD scholarship between the University of Cambridge (Faculty of Education) and Stellenbosch University (Department of Education Policy Studies). In 2017, Routledge published his first monograph, Dialogue in Places of Learning. He has published peer-reviewed journal articles on South African youth with a focus on masculinities, young offenders, curriculum development and critical pedagogy.

Candice Groenewald is a research specialist at the Human Sciences Research Council. She holds a PhD in Psychology from the University of KwaZulu-Natal and a Master’s degree in Research Psychology from the University of the Western Cape. She has six publications in local and international journals and has also co-authored two book chapters as well as three technical outputs on the epidemiology of substance abuse in South Africa. She has presented 25 papers at local and international conferences and has lectured in psychology and research at the University of the Western Cape. She has been a co- investigator on various research projects, including studies related to adolescent substance abuse, families affected by adolescent substance abuse, early childhood development and education in African communities, youth and homelessness in Durban, race and identity studies, and adolescent exposure to community violence in the Western Cape. She is also interested in diverse research methodologies, including survey methodologies, phenomenological investigations, programme evaluation, life history approaches and participatory action research.

Ernest Nene Khalema is the Dean and Head of the School of Built Environment and Development Studies at the University of KwaZulu-Natal. He holds a PhD from the University of Alberta in Canada. Before joining UKZN, he was a professor in various Canadian universities since 2001 and served as chief specialistresearch at the Human Sciences Research Council where his groundbreaking work on participatory action methodologies (quantitative and qualitative), social epidemiology, critical race and gender studies, migration and mobilities, and development studies received international recognition. He is the author of several books including the forthcoming monograph entitled Affirming their Resilient Lives: Migrant Youth in Africa and the Diaspora (Sense Publishers, 2018); and co-editor of Crisis, Identity and Migration in Post-Colonial Southern Africa (Springer, 2017); Children in South African Families: Lives and Times (Cambridge Scholars Publishers, 2016); Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) in Retrospect: African Development Beyond 2015 (Springer, 2015) and Africa Yesterday, Today and Tomorrow: Exploring the Multi-dimensional Discourses on Development (Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 2013).

Alude Mahali is a research specialist at the Human Sciences Research Council and an honorary lecturer in the Department of Drama and Performance Studies at the University of KwaZulu-Natal. She holds a PhD in Performance Studies from the University of Cape Town and an MA in Theatre Making, also from the University of Cape Town. Before joining the HSRC, she taught at the Edna Manley College of the Visual and Performing Arts in Kingston, Jamaica. She has convened an international conference in the area of African theatre and performance, served as keynote speaker at youth symposia and presented at numerous international conferences. She has published several peer-reviewed articles in her research areas, which focus on intersectional identities: race, class, gender, language and youth navigational capacities. Her most recent publications look at the domestic worker trope, black womanhood, social protest and youth activism in contemporary South Africa.

Relebohile Moletsane is Professor and the JL Dube Chair in Rural Education and the Acting Director of the Centre for Critical Research on Race and Identity (CCRRI) at the University of KwaZulu-Natal. Her research interests include rurality, gender and education, sexual and reproduction health, education, and participatory visual research. She is the principal investigator of the project: Education and Emancipation: A critical, intervention-oriented investigation of obstacles and opportunities within the higher-education-and-training sector in South Africa (2013–2017). She is the co-author (with Claudia Mitchell and Naydene de Lange) of the 2017 book, Participatory Visual Methodologies: Social change Through Community and Policy Dialogue (SAGE); and co-editor (with Barbara Pini and Martin Mills) of the 2016 book, Education and the Global Rural: Feminist Perspectives (Routledge).

Sharlene Swartz is a Deputy Executive Director at the Human Sciences Research Council in South Africa,an honorary Professor of Philosophy at the University of Fort Hare and an adjunct Associate Professor of Sociology at the University of Cape Town. She holds undergraduate degrees from the University of the Witwatersrand and the University of Zululand in South Africa; a master’s degree from Harvard University and a PhD from the University of Cambridge. Her expertise and current research centre on the just inclusion of youth in a transforming society and on interpersonal and communal notions of restitution. Her work is characterised by a focus on Southern theory, emancipatory methodologies and critical race theory. She is the author or co-author of nine books, including Another Country: Everyday Social Restitution (HSRC Press, 2016); Ikasi: The Moral Ecology of South Africa’s Township Youth (Palgrave, 2009); Teenage Tata: Voices of Young South African Fathers (HSRC Press, 2009); Youth Citizenship and the Politics of Belonging (Routledge, 2013); and Moral Eyes: Cultivating Youth Engagement on Privilege, Injustice and Restitution (HSRC Press, 2018).

Share this

You might also consider these related books

1961  Large

Education in Retrospect
Policy and implementation since 1990

This book reviews curriculum policy, reform and implementation in South African education. This is an edited compilation of the key presentations and discussions that took place between education policy-makers and researchers at the HSRC-sponsored Round Table in September 2000.

Product information

Format : 168mm x 210mm
Pages : 206
ISBN 10 : 0-7969-1988-7
ISBN 13 : 978-07969-1988-5
Publish Year : 2001
Price R 191.00
1948  Large

Settling for Less
Student aspirations and higher education realities

This study is the second in the 'Student Choice Behaviour Project'. It traces learners who entered higher education and further education institutions and investigates the factors which influenced them. It also considers the achievability of two of the key objectives of the National Plan for Higher Education: to increase the participation rate in the system; and to shift the balance of enrolments away from the humanities and towards the study of business and commerce, and science, engineering and technology.

Product information

Format : 210mm x 280mm
Pages : 120
ISBN 10 : 0-7969-2045-1
ISBN 13 : 978-07969-2045-4
Publish Year : 2004
Price R 180.00
2250  Large

Studying Ambitions
Pathways from grade 12 and the factors that shape them

Broadly concerned with grade 12 learner aspirations for the future, this monograph hones in on the aspiration to study education and to enter the teaching profession. The National Policy Framework for Teacher Education and Development in South Africa highlights this as a crucial area for further research - a need which this study attempts to address.

Product information

Format : 280mm x 210mm (Soft Cover)
Pages : 152
ISBN 10 : 0-7969-2243-8
ISBN 13 : 978-07969-2243-4
Publish Year : 2009
Rights : World Rights
Price R 133.00
2299  Large

Community, self and identity
Educating South African university students for citizenship

Education in South Africa is in crisis. Low literacy and numeracy rates, poor discipline, and a sense of despair pervade the education landscape. At the same time, educators are called upon to achieve more, with universities tasked to produce graduates capable of exercising responsible and reflective citizenship in a competitive and globalising world. However, universities face very complex demands and resource constraints. In this sobering context, this book provides an opportunity to learn from a bold experiment in teaching and learning taking place across two very different South African universities, one historically black, and one historically white and Afrikaans.

Product information

Format : 235mm x 168mm (Soft Cover)
Pages : 224
ISBN 10 : 978-07969-2398-1
ISBN 13 : 978-07969-2398-1
Publish Year : 2013
Rights : World Rights
Price R 250.00