The Human Sciences Research Council (HSRC)

Visit South Africa's official Covid-19 resource portal
Teaching The  Native 9780796925145

About the book

If you are sitting in a South African school or university right now, you need to put aside 1948 and "Bantu Education" as a primary target of enquiry – these were little more than steps along a road that was already paved – and study when, where and how your institution came into being in the first place. This book joins the growing body of work (much of it by South African scholars) displacing the many mind-numbingly dull texts loaded with assumptions and logics that, in the case of South Africa, reify a simplified colonial explanation of the past. Generations of students, educators and policymakers have suffered enough through tedious though inaccurate history books disguised as dispassionate, impartial views of "the facts."

Yet as important as new scholarship is to a young democracy just two decades old, it is not enough. What is absolutely necessary is a fundamental reform of the very way in which history is taught in South Africa from kindergarten through graduate school, from teacher training and curriculum design to the policy boards at provincial and Ministerial levels. For if we are to understand how this country, South Africa, came to be the way it is, then the primary documents of its history must be integrated into the curriculum. Every student and teacher must know the South African Native Affairs Commission, the Act of Union, the policy documents and speeches of Rhodes, Milner, and the actual individuals designing policies for "Natives". From these documents, a picture emerges of the structures of Empire, the actual ways in which its logics, assumptions and practices operated in reality and purposely supported a system of inequality that has endured for over a century. In the texts and lives of those seemingly dull commissions and acts, the language used by the "Lords" and "Sirs" of the British Empire, the grant proposals and studies, the colonial office memos and meeting agendas, the mountainous data sets from questions asked and not asked, those little daily hegemonic interactions from generations of colonial staff and their international partners, we gain the ability to understand the structures that have made inequality in South Africa so intransigent.

During their careers, many British colonial administrators worked throughout the Empire in places like Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania, Malawi, then-Rhodesia and South Africa as well as West Africa, the Caribbean, and India. They drew lessons from these occupied lands, from the original colonial laboratory, Ireland, and of course from the impoverished cities of England as industrialization ravished communities and generations. For these reasons, we must fully investigate the ways in which past and contemporary experiences throughout Britain and the lands it conquered became instructive for this period of South African history.

When the Union of South Africa came into effect in 1910, there was already a strong Empire-wide precedent of unequal education to which its architects could refer. Milner's "kindergarten" could point to a wealth of experience, from the Macaulay Minute and the Shuttleworth Report in the colonies, to the Education Act of 1870 in Britain itself. Education in the southern United States brought policy makers from London and South Africa in increasing contact with their American counterparts. Intellectually speaking, much of the matter was settled during the South African Native Affairs Commission of 1903-05, which acted as a battle cry for scholars to justify maldistribution and inequity as resulting from qualities innate to Africans. Therefore, it is fundamentally flawed to assert the existence of an equitable education system that unfortunately became tarnished by the National Party. It was Charles Loram, not Hendrik Verwoerd, who lobbied, studied and garnered international support for a race-based differentiated education system. It was the commissions of Phelps-Stokes, not Eiselen, which called for changes in the education of all African people to secure a massive, expendable and immobile force of manual workers. It was not the 1953 Bantu Education Act but the very Act of Union written not by L.J. du Plessis and the Broederbond but by Lord Alfred Milner and his "kindergarten" of Oxford "gentlemen," that entrenched educational inequity as a foundation of South Africa's constitution.

About the author

Joseph Daniel Reilly is a scholar and activist from the United States of America. He joined the anti-apartheid movement during the National Union of Mineworkers strike in 1986, organising conferences, speaking, writing and researching during the anti-apartheid and post-apartheid era. Professor Ben Magubane invited him to join the doctoral programme at the University of Connecticut and Joe completed his PhD in 1995. In addition to his decades-long commitment to South African scholarship and liberation, Professor Reilly has worked in Switzerland, Southeast Asia, the Middle East and North Africa.

Endorsements

In 2015 South African universities exploded – statues fell, students protested, and the entire edifice of South African education was thrown into question. Teaching the Native provides an invaluable historical explanation for the controversies that currently bedevil South African education.

Artfully written, with a keen eye for historical nuance and detail, Joseph Reilly takes us on an epic journey through the history of South African educational policy, demonstrating the global and transnational connections between the South African university and British imperialism and American racism. He deftly weaves a story of how education, far from being a neutral 'technocratic' solution to inequality, has actually played a key role in creating societies structured in dominance. His analysis, which demonstrates that the present dissatisfaction within the South African academy is a predictable outcome of its history, also provides a valuable blueprint for how to rebuild South African education in the 21st century. It is a 'must read' for activists, policy-makers, students, academics, and politicians.
Zine Magubane, Associate Professor of Sociology, Boston College

Product information

Format : 198mm x 148mm
Pages : 308
ISBN 13 : 978-0-7969-2514-5
Publish Year : January 2016
Rights : World Rights

Introduction

  • Why Anthropology?

Chapter I

Anthropology and Education

  • Some Theoretical Issues in Educational Historiography
  • Some Thoughts on Anthropology, Representation and History
  • Conclusion

Chapter II

The Bourgeois Turn: The Nursery of Milner's Kindergarten

  • The Education of the British Working Class
  • Ireland: The Colonial Laboratory
  • apitalist Education Policy in Colonized Jamaica
  • Mixed Signals: The Bourgeois Veneer in Indian Education
  • Conclusion

Chapter III

South Africa Before 1900

  • Introduction
  • Cecil Rhodes as Context
  • Missionaries and "Peaceful Subjugation"

Chapter IV

Removing the Gloves in the New Century: The Education Debates

  • Introduction
  • Education and the Solution of the Crisis of African Labour
  • The Missions Fall in Line

Chapter V

The Two USAs

  • African-American Education in the Southern United States
  • Educational Foundations: Guiding Inequity
  • Exporting the Model

Chapter VI

Charles Templeman Loram: Forefather of Bantu Education

  • Introduction
  • A Critical Look at The Education of the South African Native
  • Conclusion

Chapter VII

The Alliance for Regress

  • Introduction
  • Pan-African Otherness: The Phelps-Stokes Commissions
  • The Advisory Committee on Education in the Colonies
  • Modern Craniology: Intelligence Tests
  • Conclusion

Chapter VIII

Functionalism and the International Institute of African Languages and Cultures: Whoring for Empire

  • Malinowski Delivers His "Nig Lec."
  • Conclusion

Chapter IX

Resistances: The Struggle for Education

  • Introduction
  • African Responses to Colonial Education
  • W.E.B. Du Bois: A Passion for Justice
  • Conclusion

Chapter X

Conclusions

  • Introduction
  • Clearing the Way for Apartheid: South Africa in the 1930s Legacies
  • Some Last Thoughts on Education and the Cultivation of Differenc

Bibliography

Index

Share this

You might also consider these related books

2048

Socio-Economic Rights in the South African Constitution:
Theory and practice

This publication will assist researchers, students and the public in their understanding of socio-economic rights. The book considers whether the rights listed in the Bill of Rights have been given effect to and gives an understanding of the processes followed by the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) in monitoring such rights.

Product information

Format : 140mm x 205mm
Pages : 169
ISBN 10 : 0-7969-1981-X
ISBN 13 : 978-07969-1981-6
Publish Year : 2001
Price R 170.00
2231  Large

State of the Nation: South Africa 2008

State of the Nation: South Africa 2008 is the fifth volume in the annual series published by the HSRC Press. This volume will feature a range of pertinent and captivating contemporary viewpoints on South African politics, society, economy and international relations. As with earlier editions, commentary is drawn from the ranks of academics, political analysts, civil society and the research community.

Product information

Format : 148mm x 210mm (Soft Cover)
Pages : 400
ISBN 10 : 0-7969-2199-7
ISBN 13 : 978-07969-2199-4
Publish Year : 2009
Rights : World Rights
Price R 191.00
2109  Large

State of the Nation: South Africa 2005-2006

2109
State of the Nation: South Africa 2005-2006 is the third in the HSRCs exciting annual volume of essays on aspects of contemporary politics, economics, society and international relations in South Africa. This series has, in a relatively short period, become established as part of the annual South African scholarly calendar. Coverage in the media, international as well as South African, has been extensive; controversies have been stirred; both previous volumes have been prescribed as university texts locally and abroad; they have found their way into South African embassies around the world and foreign embassies in South Africa; and most importantly, many ordinary South Africans have purchased the books simply to find out more about the complex and fascinating country we live in.

Product information

Format : 148mm x 210mm
Pages : 568
ISBN 10 : 0-7969-2115-6
ISBN 13 : 978-07969-2115-4
Publish Year : 2006
Price R 220.00
2303  Large

State of the Nation: South Africa 2012-2013
Addressing Inequality and Poverty

2303

The new edition, State of the Nation 2012–2013, will continue to stimulate contemporary debates on key issues in a significant way, helping to shape public knowledge, policies, political actions and individual and collective decisions. The new edition will offer diverse angles on inequality and poverty in South Africa in one compelling and comprehensive collection.

Product information

Format : 240mm x 168mm (Soft Cover)
ISBN 10 : 978-07969-2422-3
ISBN 13 : 978-07969-2422-3
Publish Year : 2013<br>Open Access available November 2013
Rights : World Rights
Price R 295.00